Paarl Boys' High (Boishaai) vs Grey College Historic Overview 1950 – 2012

May 24 • Premier Schools, School, School Rugby Overview • 9035 Views • 2 Comments on Paarl Boys' High (Boishaai) vs Grey College Historic Overview 1950 – 2012

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (1 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)

Paarl Boys’ High (1868) and Grey College(1855) are among the oldest schools in South Africa with both schools having a significant pedigree of rugby history, heritage and tradition. They first played each other in 1950 and did not have a regular fixture every year due to the distance between the schools. Grey and Paarl Boys’ High (also known as Boishaai) played each other 20 times from 1950 up to 1995 and since then it became an annual fixture. In total they have now played 39 matches with Grey having won 31, Paarl Boys won 6 and 2 Draws. The average score for these matches over the last 62 years is 21-10 in Grey’s favour suggesting that it is usually not a big scoring affair but that Grey clearly has the upper hand when it comes to matches between these two old rivals.

The Paarl Boys’ High vs. Grey College Interschools has now evolved to be one of the Premier Interschools in South Africa and will be televised LIVE on SuperSport 5 at 1:45pm on Saturday 26 May, 2012 from Brug Street in the Paarl. Currently both Boishaai and Grey are among the top 4 top ranked rugby schools in South Africa.

Scores Through The Years 1950-2012

Year Grey HJS
2012 18 28
2011 15 15
2010 32 12
2009 50 8
2008 34 24
2007 48 24
2006 20 5
2005 38 13
2004 38 3
2003 27 16
2002 23 6
2001 38 15
2000 10 17
1999 34 16
1998 20 6
1997 20 16
1996 9 16
1995 18 6
1993 0 0
1989 23 6
1987 31 14
1984 19 14
1984 32 12
1983 0 14
1980 13 4
1979 13 15
1978 29 13
1977 29 13
1974 21 7
1973 24 0
1971 Grey won
1960 14 0
1960 11 3
1957 3 8
1956 13 3
1954 6 3
1954 8 3
1953 12 9
1950 10 6

Highlights over the Years

Mannetjies Roux in 1968 playing in Paarl Boys High Old Boy jersey


In 1956 Boishaai traveled up north to play Grey in Bloemfontein and it was during this game that legendary Springbok center Mannetjies Rouxfrom Paarl Boys’ High was first noted by Sports Editor from Die Volksblad Herman le Roux, who then predicted that Roux would be a future Springbok. Although Grey won 13 – 3, Roux had a sublime game for Boishaai and it was only six years later that he scored that famous try (again in Bloemfontein) against the 1964 British Lions of Arthur Smith.


In 1974 the first SA Schools team was selected and Grey College had two representatives – Jan Geldenhuys and Gerhard Weitz. Grey beat Paarl Boys High during a festival occasion in the Paarl 21-7

1974: Grey College (21) Paarl Boys High (7)

During the late seventies two very famous Springbok and SA Schools wings (Carel du Plessis and Jaco Reinach) played for Paarl Boys High and Grey College respectively and later became team mates during the 1986 Springboks against the New Zealand Cavaliers. Carel, prince of wings from Boishaai, played in 1978 against Grey which Grey won 29-13.

Jan Geldenhuys (SA Schools) leading Grey against Boishaai in 1974

A year later, in 1979 Jaco Reinach (double Springbok in Rugby and Athletics) was Grey’s wing against Boishaai in a match won by Boishaai 15-13. In 1980, Jaco again played first team for Grey against Boishaai in a Grey team that starred 5 SA Schools players including Jurie Erwee (Captain), Jaco Reinach, Joepie vd Merwe, Koen Pieterse, and Hendrik Daffue. Grey won 13-4. Helgardt Muller (who played SA Schools in ’81 and ’82) and Joubert Strydom (SA Schools Nuffield Cricket Captain) was also part of the 1980 Grey College First Team.


Jaco Reinach (double Springbok from Grey) played against Paarl Boys High in 1979 & 1980 and later became Springbok team mates with Carel du Plessis (Boishaai 1978) against the 1986 NZ Cavaliers.

Grey College 1980 First Team won13-4 against Paarl Boys High and included 5 SA Schools Players (Jurie Erwee (captain), Jaco Reinach, Joepie vd Merwe, Koen Pieterse, and Hendrik Daffue)


In 1993, the only SA Schools Captain (to date) that became Springbok Captain, was the Paarl Boys’ High Captain, Corne Krige. Against Grey College, Corne was leading the Boishaai team from the front and will always be remembered for his crash tackles during this game which kept the scores at a 0-0 draw.


The last Boishaai team to beat Grey was in 2000 which boasted the likes of JD Moller, Neil Fullard and Jasper Loubser who did not have their equal in schoolboy rugby that year come scrumtime and 10 + years later is still regarded as one of the best scrummaging pack in schoolboy rugby over the last decade. Grey had future provincial players such as Tewis de Bruyn, Bobbie Joubert and Barry Goedewhen Boishaai won the game 17-10 in the Paarl.

JD Moller – Boishaai 2000


The last Interschools in the Paarl in 2010 had an unfimiliar lead up to the First Team match for Grey when all their A teams in respective age groups (u/14A, u/15A, u/16A) lost against Boishaai on the main field including Grey’s 3rd and 2nd teams. The table was set for the First Team match to be a cracker before Grey took the field. However, the 2010 Grey team had probably the best backline in modern day schoolboy rugby and jumped into 3rd gear in the second half to ran in some sublime tries that resulted in Grey winning 32-12 after being down 11-12 at halftime. That Grey backline during the season of 2010 could contain at one stage up to 6 current and future SA Schools players –Johan Goosen, William Small-Smith, Paul Jordaan, Dries Swanepoel, Jan Serfontein and Kevin Luiters all went on to represent SA Schools in 2010/11. See below some video highlights from the 2010 Interschools:

Grey College First Team 2010 beat Paarl Boys High in Paarl 32 -12


Last year the 2011 Boishaai team nearly caused a major upset in Bloemfontein to end Grey’s long standing winning streak. Boishaai wing JP le Roux went over in the corner with the scores tied at 15 all and time virtually up on the clock. He was adjudged in touch by the touch judge and this was later proved to be a very good call on photographic evidence. At the final whistle Grey and Boishaai drew 15 all.

2012 Season

History will show that Grey is the overwhelming favourite to win once again, but looking at the current season, perhaps the wise pundit will ignore history for a change. Both teams have very similar results this season so far. They have played 3 mutual opponents, both winning against Monnas and Waterkloof and both losing to Affies. It is therefore on paper a very even contest and too close to call. Both teams also suffered some injuries to key players with perhaps Boishaai being hardest hit with their talisman No 7 flank Ryno vd Merwe out with concussion and playmaker at 13 Neil Maritz out due to a broken thumb. Grey will miss captain Henco Greyling due to a shoulder injury sustained against Selborne 3 weeks ago. An interesting twist to the 2012 tale is the fact that the Boishaai left wing Dante vd Merwe is the son of Grey Old Boy Ruan vd Merwe (1986) who also played Grey First Team and Free State Cravenweek in 1985 and 86. For which team Ruan is supporting on Saturday still remains a mystery and will only be revealed once the final whistle has blown!

Ruan vd Merwe (Grey& Free State Cravenweek– 1985 & 86) and Dante vd Merwe (HJS Paarl – 2012)

Grey College 2012 Season

Played 12 Won 10 , Lost 2

Date Vs For Against
2012/03/17 Duineveld 17 10
2012/03/24 Hentie Cilliers 37 25
2012/04/05 Paarl Gim 29 45
2012/04/07 Westville BHS 43 8
2012/04/09 Monument 8 0
2012/04/14 Jim Fouche 17 7
2012/04/21 HTS Louis Botha 26 14
2012/04/28 Waterkloof 37 20
2012/04/30 EG Jansen 41 22
2012/05/05 Selborne 54 5
2012/05/12 AHS (Affies) 27 35
2012/05/19 Sentraal 60 12

Paarl Boys High 2012 Season

Played 11, Won 10 , Lost 1

Date Vs For Against
2012/03/14 De Kuilen 30 0
2012/03/17 Langenhoven Gim 36 0
2012/03/20 Tygerberg 25 0
2012/04/05 Lord Wandsworth 72 0
2012/04/07 Nelspruit 30 5
2012/04/09 Waterkloof 19 18
2012/04/14 Outeniqua 33 26
2012/04/21 Rondebosch 24 3
2012/04/28 AHS (Affies) 14 22
2012/04/30 Monument 32 28
2012/05/12 SACS 19 10

Paarl Boys High First Team 2012


Grey College was founded on 13 October 1855 when Sir George Grey, the then Governor of the Cape Colony, paid a visit to the Orange Free State Republic and donated a sum of money towards the establishment of an institution for higher education. The foundation stone was laid by Jacobus Nicolaas Boshoff, the second President of the Orange Free State Republic, on 13 October 1856.

The school was officially opened on 17 January 1859 and the first headmaster was the Reverend Andrew Murray. It is the third-oldest school in South Africa and the oldest north of the Orange River.[1]

Afrikaans- and English-speaking pupils study under one roof, but each language group is educated in separate classrooms and in its own mother tongue.

Grey has served Bloemfontein, the Free State, South Africa and the world well over the past 150 years.Grey has been able to make adjustments and remain relevant in a changing environment in which it has developed, grown and excelled.The brand is known and revered throughout South Africa and even internationally and the products of the school make a positive difference wherever they are.Parallel medium education, tolerance, respect for others and loyalty to the school are not only traditions, but firm foundations in a global village.Grey is structured on these foundations and it is constantly adapting to new developments. The wave of change washing over our country confirms the value of Grey’s traditions.

Grey has produced 39 Springbok rugby players. Since WW II it has produced more Springbok players than any other school in SA.

List of Grey Springboks:

Debut Year Name
1896 Herman van Broekhuizen
1912 Boetie McHardy
1921 Sarel Strauss
1937 Louis Babrow
1937 Harry Martin
1938 Piet de Wet
1955 Popeye Strydom
1965 John Wessels
1963 Gert Cilliers
1970 Johan Spies
1971 Morné du Plessis
1972 Dawie Snyman
1974 Jackie Snyman
1976 Theuns Stofberg
1977 Robbie Blair
1986 Jaco Reinach
1986 Helgard Muller
1992 Pieter Muller
1992 Heinrich Fuls
1992 Johan Styger
1993 Ruben Kruger
1993 Naka Drotske
1994 Ollie le Roux
1997 Werner Swanepoel
1999 Charl Marais
2002 CJ van der Linde
2004 Gerrie Britz
2006 Ruan Pienaar
2006 Francois Steyn
2007 Jannie du Plessis
2007 Bismarck du Plessis
2007 Tiaan Liebenberg
2008 Adriaan Strauss
2008 Heinrich Brussow
2009 Wian du Preez
2010 Deon Stegmann
2010 Flip van der Merwe
2010 Andries Strauss
2011 Coenie Oosthuizen

There were 5 Old Greys in the 1999 World Cup squad, Ollie le Roux, Naka Drotské, Ruben Kruger, Werner “Smiley” Swanepoel and Pieter Müller.

In the 2007 winning World Cup team there were again 5 Old Greys, CJ van der Linde, Jannie and Bismarck du Plessis, Ruan Pienaar and Francois Steyn.

Grey had 6 representatives in the 2011 Rugby World Cup Springbok team in New Zealand – Jannie du Plessis, Bismarck du Plessis, Frans Steyn, Ruan Pienaar, Heinrich Brussow, and CJ van der Linde.


Hoër Jongenskool Paarl (also known as Boishaai, Paarl Boys’, BHS or HJS) is one of the oldest schools in South Africa. Built in 1868 the school’s rich history is filled with tradition and pride. The first building to house the school was a granary on Zeederbergplein, the owner of which was mr. D. Beyers (a close friend to the first headmaster, Rev. Jeffreys). The first years of the school were unstable ones, with the school increasing in size every year, larger facilities were required frequently. The grounds on which the school stands today were originally formed part of the farm Berlyn owned by mr. P.J Malherbe.

Paarl Boys’ High has featured in the academic merit list of the Western Cape for ten years running and has been featuring in the top ten for the duration as well, making it one of the top academic schools in the province. The school is bilingual, with classes in English and Afrikaans and has been maintaining a 100% pass rate for over a decade.

Paarl Boys produced 17 Springboks so far.

Debut Year Name
1910 Dirkie de Villiers
1910 Cocky Hahn
1924 Champion Myburgh
1924 Jack Bester
1928 Boy Louw
1933 Manie Geere
1933 Fanie Louw
1938 Ben du Toit
1949 Ryk van Schoor
1955 Theuns Briers
1958 Piet du Toit
1960 Mannetjies Roux
1963 Haas Schoeman
1982 Carel du Plessis
1999 Corné Krige
2004 Gurthro Steenkamp

Legendary “Oom” Boy Louw and Carel du Plessis also coached the Springboks. Cornè Krige is still the only SA Schools captain who went on to captain the Springboks as well.

Ryk van Schoor’s son Theuns is currently a teacher at Boishaai and coaches the u/16’s as well as the Western Province u/18 Cravenweek team. Carel du Plessis’s son (Jean-Luc) is playing flyhalf for the 2012 1st XV.


By Pollie Pollard & Nico du Plessis

Related Posts